The New Year is kicking off with a bang. Bootup Labs moved into our new offices on Sunday (Cambie at Hastings, the Flack Block - come visit!) On Monday morning Danny was in the Financial Post (actually, @trevoro from @layerboom has much longer quotes on page 2). Then on Tuesday (technically yesterday as I'm posting this), I got a call from @lalondetcbc and ended up with a short CBC TV segment talking about whether bloggers should be legally required to disclose payments and other bonuses they receive. I was "opposite" Rebecca / Miss 604. That is, it was supposed to be opposing view points.
Rebecca is an excellent blogger. She is a professional blogger (i.e. makes her living from her blogging activities). It's great that she's decided to use CMP.ly to indicate her disclosures: it shows the kind of honesty and transparency that makes her a great blogger. Do we need a law for it? Well, the FTC in the US thinks it does, but the guidelines seem over broad - a $5 discount at a restaurant and a positive review could net you an $11K fine? Of course, they say it will be on a case by case basis. Hmmm ... a law that is hard to enforce and is applied inconsistently? Sounds like trouble to me! I like John Chow's disclosure policy -- everything he posts he's making money from. This is a pure case of media literacy - people need to learn about the sources they are consuming and make their own decisions. Of course, journalists aren't covered under these laws at all. Why not? Good question, and quotes like this one in a Reason Magazine article don't inspire confidence: "Yet I don't remember any reviewer in any print publication ever disclosing that the record, the movie, the meal or the vacation was free." Lastly, it seems like Rebecca and I were set up to have opposing viewpoints, since we seem to be on the same page. Oh well, at least they spelled my name right :P I have a few quotes bookmarked under the tag FTC Endorsement Guidelines for further reading.
Comments
Video not working
Maybe it's just me, but I can't get the videos to play in either Firefox or Safari... :-(
Worked for me in the past…
…but the crazy not really permalinks non embeddable CBC website doesn't work too consistently, so I'm not surprised.
I respect Rebecca and Tris
I respect Rebecca and Tris for deciding to use it. However, mandating it is ridiculous. Despite that, if this topic gets enough attention, the effect could be more internet readers being more careful and taking trust more seriously and demanding transparency from their sources of information. No third party needs to step in, puleeease
I decided to follow Rebecca's
I decided to follow Rebecca's lead and use CMP.ly, but Boris you do make a good point about scale. Yeah a $5 drink vs a $500 phone, big difference.
I figure I will stick with my general disclosure for 99% of posts and for specific cases detail the nature of the whatever I received.
Disclosure
The proposed laws in the US are purely aimed at controlling all online media as it has become unruly and profitable and both at the same time. We Bloggers are out of line, clearly- nobody is telling us what to say. Ironic, because that's very similar to many conservative's dreams of the "free market". The big media houses are unhappy that independent journalism is once again making a comeback and people like Senators Rockefeller and Snowe are just being opportunistic, making a name for themselves or have been bought by the media corps.
What's worse? Someone buys me lunch and I walk away with a favorable impression, and then I write a blog that a few thousand people read? Or Rupert Murdoch sends a memo out to his army of "reporters" on what they can and can't write? and his influential and subjective viewpoint reaches millions through supposedly credible media sources.If there's nothing wrong with Newscorp's model of journalism there's nothing wrong with independent bloggers. Getting fined for exercising my freedom to say what I want, that sounds like an abuse of my individual rights.
SCale
For the record if someone gave me a Car or $5,000 I would disclose that. I agree with the scale comment too. Little things though, come on.