osOpinion: The Ultimate Lock-In

I said some nice/hopeful things about the next version of MS Office and XML formats. Well, I might be completely wrong, according to an osOpinion article entitled The Ultimate Lock-In.

The first is the possible DMCA implications of trying to open Office 2003 documents without Microsoft's blessing. Just as Dmitri Sklyarov found himself in a world of trouble for writing software to break Adobe's encryption for its E-Book format, developers who write software that will open "protected" Office 2003 documents may find themselves facing criminal charges under the DMCA.

Comments

OTOH...

People posting to this Slashdot article about a similarly negative article say basically, that these articles are full of it & the Office2003 implementation of XML is perfectly good.

Maybe not that depressing

... the divestiture of AT&T and the unbundling to PSTN switches and interfaces (billing, datanses, order systems etc) is a good precedent.

A proprietary MS document is like a packet that cannot be parsed by a switch.
So perhaps it can be regulated that the format be an open specification.